...
Attendees
Goals
- How to support/permit test ARKs
- First draft policy statement
Discussion items
Time | Item | Who | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
announcements | |||
N2T-based test ARKs for non-EZID users This is a much narrower version of the proposal I brought in last month, which was to expand the role of NAAN registry to record shoulders under the four non-institutional NAANs. We need agreement on how INCIPIT might proceed with N2T-based test ARKs that do not conflict with EZID test ARKs. A major benefit of the proposal would be to protect exclusive "test" shoulder access rights of both EZID and INCIPIT. Proposed: With its oversight role for the NAAN namespace, this group agrees to reserve, under the 99999 NAAN,
Some discussion:
|
The current proposal has no impact on the NAAN registry. The test shoulders reserved in this way would be recorded for now in a separate file. | John |
| |
First draft policy statement on NAAN assignment and update. I pulled some text out of the github repo's README.md file to create a new Policy.md file. The biggest change was to add a small section on update policy: Update policy for NAAN curators is mostly about doing one's best to verify that the request is coming from a legitimate source that is authorized to represent the original NAAN-holding organization. The biggest risk is a change to the organizational URL (resolver) for ARKs with that NAAN that rely on N2T, since such a change will affect their resolution. Things to watch out for are (a) mistaken requests and (b) spurious attempts to misdirect someone's ARKs (never happened yet). Things are not always obvious, for example, a request came in for a new organizational URL that, by itself, returned a 404 error; while it seemed like a mistake, and it still returns a 404 error, it is nonetheless a valid base URL for a local ARK resolver. | John |
|
Action items
- Clarify and add documentation pertaining to the "reserved" status of 99999 NAAN John Kunze
- Document the test shoulders assigned to the 99999 NAAN John Kunze
- John Kunze Will add Julien Antoine Raemy Maria Gould aurélien conraux to the github repository
- aurélien conraux Will reach out to Archives départementales de la Mayenne regarding N2T inquiry for updating records regarding organization URL
- Bertrand Caron Will send out an email message to the English ARKs list to encourage community to update their organization information for the ARK registry