5m | NAAN registry URL confirmation | all | Sheila: correct entry, but Portico re-working landing pages for ARKs Mark: Correct entry Greg: (UCSB) will followup Curtis: EZID, works fine Adrien: will check Bertrand: works fine Tom: works correctly, registry entry correct |
45m | prioritizing Experts Day spec issues | all | - Literal character repertoire changes: allow '~', but disallow '#' (which is is reserved in URIs fragments and LOD): Greg – are there existing arks with # - if there was no objection, probably safe to assume ok ; to be clear: ok at end of URL, but not part of ARK id itself APPROVED
- Make the first '/' optional, so that ark:/12345/678 is equivalent to ark:12345/678. This would match a near universal practice in other id schemes, and is a commonplace and understandable mistake that currently penalizes ARK users and potential adopters. Seems to have become common practice NOT to include first '/'; do not expect it to affect existing ARKs; TOM: caution - without / in FS environment, will 404; JOHN: when ready, publishing new ARKs, do not have to use initial '/'; TOM after change, must support existing arks (that have '/', but are submitted without; We are saying arks for an object, with or without slash, are equivalent to each other; should able to resolve (to that same object) whether or not submission as the '/' ; BERTRAND re ':' Is this a URI compatibility issue? JOHN: per spec should be encoded, so we will have to include this in compatibility question APPROVED
- Parsers (resolvers) should check for inflections (final punctuation character combinations) before normalization of final structural characters ('/' and '.'), for example, given "ark:/12345/678./", parsers should check if "./" is an inflection and only normalize to "ark:/12345/678" if no inflection is matched Resolving code should check for inflections first, strip off if found, then do resolution to stored ARKid when receiving an ARK for storage or for resolution; GREG: concerns; EG '.' at end of ARK that has been cut and pasted: is '.' part of ARK or just punctuation - Roxana: question about suffixes; JOHN: importance of normalizing ARKs before storing (i.e. strip off punctuation at end)
|