Time/Place
- Time: 11:30am Eastern Daylight Time US (UTC-4)
- Dial-in Number: (712) 775-7035
- Participant Code: 479307#
- International numbers: Conference Call Information
Attendees
- Julie Allinson
- Chris Awre
Carolyn Caizzi (for Evviva Weinraub)Robert CartolanoAaron Choate- Stefano Cossu
- Dan Coughlin
Tom Cramer- Jon Dunn (notetaker)
- Declan Fleming
- Maude Francis
- Mike Giarlo
- Wolfram Horstmann
Neil Jefferies- Debra Kurtz
- Susan Lafferty
- Jonathan Markow
- Steve Marks
- Tom Murphy
- Sandy Payette
- Matthias Razum
Robin Lindley Ruggaber- Dan Santamaria
Jon Stroop- Jim Tuttle
- Keith Webster
Evviva Weinraub- David Wilcox
- Andrew Woods
- Maurice York
Agenda
Topic Semantic versioning and release schedule Membership update and final push Fedora's upcoming 20th anniversaryLead Notes David Andrew Fedora and Modeshape Andrew / Stefano David David CNI Meeting David
Previous Actions
None mentioned.
Minutes
1. Preservation statement (David)
- Ready to distribute to the community pending any final comments
- Short 2-pager explaining what Fedora provides for digital preservation; followup document will contain more detail. Suggest adding to website; send out to mailing list for further community feedback.
- Susan: Suggest adding definition of fixity
- ACTION: Susan will add footnote
- Dan: Not clear why fixity is listed as both a current feature and upcoming feature
- David: Future refers to potential enhancements related to fixity - may want to clarify language
- Next steps for getting it out?
- Send out email that includes context about how/why this document was created
- Who should send? Leadership Group chair (Declan)
- ACTION: David will follow up with Declan
- Stefano: Where should it go on the website?
- David suggests under Features heading, but may need spot to consolidate documents like this (under Resources?)
2. Semantic versioning and release schedule (Andrew)
- Moving to semantic versioning and managing the change
- Two parts to this issue:
- Move to strict semantic versioning - seems to be consensus around this
- Main reason we have not moved is "Fedora 4" branding, so need to be careful about this change
- Decide on frequency and nature of releases
- Limit number of major releases (i.e. releases that change API in a way that's not backward compatible or require significant backend upgrades)
- Consensus seems to be no more than one major release per year (and only when necessary, so could be less than once per year)
- Move to strict semantic versioning - seems to be consensus around this
- Julie: Don't let PR issues stop us from moving forward with semantic versioning
- Jonathan: Need to move away from the Fedora 4 brand
- Find examples of other products that have undergone similar transitions
- Stefano: Chrome, Firefox?
- Are there other open source examples?
- Need to keep in mind people who only follow Fedora casually (i.e. not on mailing lists)
- Andrew: Suggest trying to finish up API spec this calendar year then spend following 6 months (first half 2017) to align Fedora implementation with API spec -> Fedora 5.0
- Start planning messaging strategy in future calls or meeting at CNI
3. Fedora and Modeshape (Andrew/Stefano)
- Suggestion arose on list to replace Fedora backend with something other than Modeshape
- Aaron Coburn (Amherst) working in codebase to better separate generic Fedora functionality from Modeshape-specific code
- Fedora API spec allows for alternative implementations of Fedora, e.g. Ben Armintor Cavendish proof-of-concept (mainly for sanity testing of API spec)
- Schedule F2F meetings after API spec release to discuss designs?
- Risk of splintering community or affecting reputation?
- Need to do whatever we can to make sure people in community who might have issues bring those issues to the community to be addressed
- Some tension from those coming into repository community from Ruby on Rails background but not library or Java background
- Get Hydra Architecture Working Group more involved?
- Next steps?
4. Membership update and final push (David)
- Projecting $562,250 in funding, only $17,750 short of annual goal ($580,000)
- ACTION: All- Please help reach out to new member prospects
- Let David know if he can help in terms of template letters, etc.
5. Fedora Camp NYC (David)
- 16 registrants so far
- Camp starts in about a month
- Need a few more in order to break even
6. CNI Meeting (David)
- Agenda filling out
- ACTION: David will add topic on semantic versioning / Fedora brand messaging
7. Fedora's upcoming 20th anniversary (David)
- 20th anniversary of initial paper
- How should we celebrate with the community?
- Send ideas to mailing list
Actions