Page History

...

The Alpha-1 benchmark test results are from June 2013:

• https://github.com/futures/ff-jmeter-testResults
• Fedora 3 Test Results
• Fedora 4 test results

These tests ingested a very small number of objects/containers (10), and files ranging from 1 byte to 100MB.

Alpha-3 Test

...

• Number of Objects: In initial testing, all nodes were created as children of a single node.  This resulted in degraded ingest performance as the repository size grew, particularly after 20K objects.
• Datastream Size: In my experience, the larger files in those tests (1MB, 8MB, 100MB) are fairly typical for high-res images and audio/video derivatives, and audio/video masters are much larger.

Testing full-scale ingest would take more disk space and time than we have available.  So it probably makes more sense to do two separate tests:

• Many Objects: 25K objects with small datastreams (100KB): 2.5GB total data size
• Large Datastreams: 100 objects with larger datastreams (50MB): 5GB total data size

In addition to varying the number of objects and datastream size, it is particularly important to perform some tests on the same hardware in order to have directly-comparable data:

• Thread Test: Run the same test on the same hardware with increasing numbers of client threads
• Fedora 3/4 Comparison: Run the same tests on the same hardware with both Fedora 3 and 4

Ingest Test Matrix (Profile)

Fedora 3/4 Comparison

Using Benchtool

The ingest benchmarking tool is available on github: https://github.com/futures/benchtool

To build and run benchtool against Fedora 4 (creating 1000 objects with 1KB datastreams using 5 client threads):

git clone git@github.com:futures/benchtool.git
cd benchtool
mvn install
java -cp target/bench-tool-0.0.1-SNAPSHOT-jar-with-dependencies.jar org.fcrepo.bench.BenchToolFC4 http://localhost:8080 1000 1024 5 ingest

To run against Fedora 3 (creating 1000 objects with 1KB datastreams):

java -cp target/bench-tool-0.0.1-SNAPSHOT-jar-with-dependencies.jar org.fcrepo.bench.BenchToolFC3 http://localhost:8983/fedora fedoraAdmin fedoraAdmin 1000 1024 ingest

Running benchtool will output a running progress percentage, and then output the time to perform the ingest:

Complete ingest of 1000 files took 23301 ms

Ingest/Read/Update/Delete Test Results

Results

The Alpha-3 benchmark test results from December 2013:

• Fedora 3 and Fedora 4 test results

Create/Read/Update/Delete Test Results

Testing was performed to create, read, update and delete objects/containers in Fedora 3, Fedora 4-alpha3, and Fedora 4-alpha5 (4-current), using the cURL command-line tool (Fedora 3 test script, Fedora 4 test script).  Each test run processed 3,000 objects/containers, and each object had a single 10MB binary.  Each repository was tested twice and the average times are summarized below.

Ingest/Read/Update/Delete Test Results (Rewritten Benchtool)

A complete rewrite of our benchmarking tool in early December 2013 means that the results are not directly-comparable to earlier results with the previous version.

Image Added